¿Quién tiene la culpa y quién puede culpar a quién? Un diálogo sobre la legitimidad del castigo en contextos de exclusión social

Authors

  • Gustavo A. Beade Facultad de Derecho, Universidad de Buenos Aires
  • Rocío Lorca Facultad de Derecho, Universidad de Chile

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.5347/47.2017.42

Keywords:

Punishment, exclusion, blame, hypocrisy, complicity

Abstract

Who is Blameworthy, and Who can Blame Whom? A Dialogue about the Legitimacy of Punishment in the Face of Social Exclusion

The article presents two views about the legitimacy of punishment in contexts of social exclusion. In the first part, one of the authors defends the idea that states that do not comply with previous legal obligations cannot blame those who commit crimes related to this non-compliance. They cannot do it because they do not have the sufficient moral standing to blame according to two objections: complicity and hypocrisy. In the second part, the second author criticizes this solution and argues that because a central feature of the political relationship is its lack of reciprocity, the objections of hypocrisy and complicity are inapplicable to legal punishment.

Downloads

Published

2018-04-30

How to Cite

A. Beade, G., & Lorca, R. (2018). ¿Quién tiene la culpa y quién puede culpar a quién? Un diálogo sobre la legitimidad del castigo en contextos de exclusión social. Isonomía - Revista De teoría Y filosofía Del Derecho, (47), 135–164. https://doi.org/10.5347/47.2017.42

Issue

No. 47 (2017): Isonomía 47

Section

Research Articles

License

Copyright (c) 2017 Isonomía - Revista de teoría y filosofía del derecho

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

ITAM, the publisher, has the copyright of published articles and remaining types of publications. Publications are in open access and licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License. That means, among other things, that authors can freely share their articles, once published in Isonomía, on their personal web pages, Academia.edu, etc.. Between formal acceptance and online publication, authors can share the final drafts of their articles. In contrast, authors must seek permission to reproduce or reprint work, and mention, in the first footnote, "previously published in Isonomía, year, n. x, pp. xx-xx"..