Jurisprudencia deliberativa
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5347/61/2024/680Keywords:
precedents, deliberation, constitutional court, civil law traditionAbstract
Deliberative Precedential Reasoning
In this paper I am concerned with deliberation between constitutional courts and ordinary courts, that is, deliberation between courts. Specifically, I am concerned with the impact that the establishment of a system of descending vertical interpretive precedents may have on deliberation between courts. To this end, I first analyze the main arguments that are usually advanced against the existence of genuine precedents in the systems of the civil law legal tradition. After discussing these arguments, I show which elements of the system of precedents can favor an adequate deliberation between courts, resulting in an improvement of the quality of their decisions.
References
Aguiló, Josep, 2000: Teoría general de las fuentes del Derecho (y del orden jurídico). Barcelona, Ariel.
Bulygin, Eugenio, 1991: “Sentencia judicial y creación de derecho”, en Análisis Lógico y Derecho. Madrid, Centro de Estudios Constitucionales, pp. 355-369.
Cueto Rúa, Julio, 1961: Fuentes del derecho. Buenos Aires, Abeledo-Perrot.
Donnellan Keith, 1970: “Proper Names and Identifying Descriptions”, Synthese, 21, pp. 335-358.
Duxbury, Neil, 2008: The Nature and Authority of Precedent. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Ferreres, Víctor, 2010. “Sobre la posible fuerza vinculante de la jurisprudencia”, en Ferreres, Víctor y Xiol, Juan Antonio, El carácter vinculante de la jurisprudencia. Madrid, Fundación Coloquio Jurídico Europeo, pp. 51-56.
Gargarella, Roberto, 2021: El derecho como una conversación entre iguales. Qué hacer para que las democracias contemporáneas se abran – por fin – al dialogo ciudadano. Siglo XXI Editores Argentina.
Giuffré, Ignacio, 2023: “Deliberative Constitutionalism ‘Without Shortcuts’: On the Deliberative Potential of Cristina Lafont’s Judicial Review Theory”, Global Constitutionalism, 12, 2, pp. 215-233.
Guastini, Riccardo, 2016: Las fuentes del derecho. Fundamentos teóricos. Lima, Raguel Ediciones.
_______________, 2011: “Rule-Scepticism Restated”, en Green, Leslie y Leiter, Brian (eds.), Oxford Studies in Philosophy of Law, vol. 1. Oxford, Oxford University Press, pp. 138-161.
_______________, 2005: “A Sceptical View on Legal Interpretation”, Analisi e diritto, pp. 139-144.
Jackman, Henry, 1999: “We Live Forwards but Understand Backwards: Linguistic Practices and Future Behavior”, Pacific Philosophical Quarterly, 80, pp. 157-177.
Kripke Saul, 1980: Naming and Necessity. Cambridge, Harvard University Press.
Lafont, Cristina, 2021: Democracia sin atajos. Una concepción participativa de la democracia deliberativa. Madrid, Trotta.
MacCormick, Neil, y Summers, Robert, (eds.), 1997: Interpreting Precedents. Surrey, Ashgate.
Martí, Genoveva y Ramírez-Ludeña, Lorena, 2021: “Tolerance, Flexibility and the Application of Kind Terms”, Synthese, 198, pp. 2973-2986.
_______________, 2020: “On Whales and Fish. Two Models of Interpretation” Jurisprudence, 11, pp. 73-75.
_______________, 2016: “Legal Disagreements and New Theories of Reference”, en Capone, Alessandro y Poggi, Francesca (eds.) Pragmatics and Law. Holanda, Springer, pp. 121-137.
Martí, Josep Lluis, 2006: La república deliberativa. Barcelona, Marcial Pons.
Núñez Vaquero, Álvaro, 2022: “Constitutive Rules of Precedent. A Non-Prescriptivist Account of Stare Decisis”, Revus, 46 (DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/revus.8560).
_______________, 2020: “¿Violan los precedents la IJI? Desencuentros desde la incomprensión”, Revista de la Facultad de Derecho de PUPC, 84, pp. 303-336.
Núñez Vaquero, Álvaro, Arriagada Cáceres, Beatriz y Ampuero Hunter, Iván (eds.), 2021: Teoría y práctica del precedente. Valencia, Tirant lo Blanch.
Orozco Muñoz, Martín, 2011: La Creación judicial del derecho y el precedente vinculante. Madrid, Aranzadi.
Peczenick, Aleksander, 1997: “The Binding Force of Precedent”, en MacCormick, Neil y Summers, Robert (eds.): Interpreting Precedents. Surrey, Ashgate, pp. 461-479.
Putnam, Hilary, 1975: Mind, Language and Reality: Philosophical Papers. Vol. 2. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Ramírez-Ludeña, Lorena, 2018: “Interpretación evolutiva y flexibilidad. Un análisis crítico de la Sentencia del Tribunal Constitucional Español sobre matrimonio entre personas del mismo sexo”, Discusiones, 22, 2, pp. 153-188.
_______________, 2015. Diferencias y deferencia. Sobre el impacto de las nuevas teorías de la referencia en el derecho. Barcelona, Marcial Pons.
_______________, 2014. “Las teorías del derecho en la formación de los jueces”, Cuadernos Electrónicos de filosofía del Derecho, 30, pp. 37-59.
Ruiz Miguel, Alfonso y Laporta, Francisco, 1997: “Precedent in Spain”, en MacCormick, Neil y Summers, Robert (eds.): Interpreting Precedents. Surrey, Ashgate, pp. 259-291.
Searle, John, 1958: “Proper Names”, Mind, 67, pp. 166-173.
Valentini, Chiara, 2024: “Constitucionalismo deliberativo y control judicial. Un enfoque sistémico”, Isonomía, 61, fall.
Vilajosana, Josep Maria, 2019: “Social Facts and Law: Why the Rule of Recognition is a Convention”, en Ramírez-Ludeña, Lorena y Vilajosana, Josep Maria (eds.): Legal Conventionalism. Holanda, Springer, pp. 89-107.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Isonomía - Revista de teoría y filosofía del derecho
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
ITAM, the publisher, has the copyright of published articles and remaining types of publications. Publications are in open access and licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License. That means, among other things, that authors can freely share their articles, once published in Isonomía, on their personal web pages, Academia.edu, etc.. Between formal acceptance and online publication, authors can share the final drafts of their articles. In contrast, authors must seek permission to reproduce or reprint work, and mention, in the first footnote, "previously published in Isonomía, year, n. x, pp. xx-xx"..
